Ice King weaves a tale filled with drama, romance and men's fashion.
Finn looked at the four elemental parts of Ooo, namely Fire, Ice, Candy and Slime.
Ice King tells Finn and Jake to go to the living room. Jake asks what had happened to Ooo. Ice King decided to tell them how it had started.
Ice King saw Finn, Jake, Bmo and Susan Strong leaving Ooo on Princess Bubblegum's boat. Knowing that his 'besties' had left Ooo, he wondered what to do. He took out his notebook to look for something to do, when Patience St. Pim comes out from Ice King's room with a colorful hat put on. Ice King turned to the page that read: #3 Join a pile. Betty arrived and asked to have a date to remember.
- Gunter (flashback)
- Patience St. Pim (flashback)
- Ancient Sleeping Magi of Wish Giving (flashback)
- Leaf Man (flashback)
- Tiny Manticore (flashback)
- Princess Bubblegum (flashback)
- Slime Princess (flashback)
- Flame Princess (flashback)
- Marceline (flashback, cameo)
- Fern (flashback, cameo)
- Susan Strong (flashback, cameo)
- Beau (flashback, cameo)
- Magic Man (voice on doorbell only)
- Flame Princess is seen wearing her "normal" outfit for the first time since "Frost & Fire."
- While trying out his new suit, Ice King quotes a line from The Offspring's song "Pretty Fly (For a White Guy)," except he says "Pretty fly, for an ice guy."
- At the very end of the episode Jake says "All we needed was a little patience", a line from the song "Patience" by Guns N' Roses.
- Ice King and the Ancient Sleeping Magi of Life Giving appear to still be friends after the events of "Friends Forever."
- A flashback of Princess Bubblegum, Marceline, and Fern, waving goodbye to Finn, Jake, Susan and BMO from "The Invitation" is shown.
- Betty mentions some of the events of both "King's Ransom" and "Broke His Crown."
- As of this episode, Betty is voiced by Felicia Day instead of Lena Dunham.
- This episode was made available for download on iTunes on April 17th.