As a Cloud Person Carroll is a puffy, small, and has stubby limbs. She has cloud 'hair' that covers her left eye. As an Ice Person, she is made out of a solid angular block of ice. When she is shown as a Water Nymph she has the blue skin and flowing water hair as the other nymphs, but she wears a black one-piece swimsuit.
- "The Tower" (debut)
- Carroll takes on a different form in each of her appearances, though she always has her "hair" combed over one eye. The three forms represent different stages of the water cycle, including gas/vapor (her cloud form), solid (her ice form) and liquid (her pond and Water Nymph forms).
- In her last appearance, she is drawing pictures that include a woman with a bow and arrow and a butterfly (one of Finn's past incarnations), suggesting she might be planning to change forms again. The drawing of the woman with the bow and arrow is seen inside BMO's home as "King of Ooo."